Nominations continue

[aphrodite_mine]

Nomination clean up doesn't officially start til next week, but I'm open to getting head starts. Please comment here if:

• there is a duplicate within a fandom
• someone not in a fandom is showing up in that fandom
• a character has been approved who should have been denied
• a character has been denied who should have been approved
• a character or fandom has a typo

Do NOT comment if:

• you aren't in a fandom but a casual look makes you think that a character might not be eligible
• one of your nominations was denied and you'd like to nominate something else (sorry)
• one of your nominations hasn't been reviewed yet and its been more than 24 hours
• your question or comment is not directly linked to nominations clean up

Here's the tag set for perusal and for nominations if you haven't made yours yet.

Comments are not screened. If you would prefer a screened comment, please use the comment post.

Comments

[hebethen]

If an uncategorized fandom is actually a TV show/book/game/other unambiguous medium category, is that a matter for AO3 tag wranglers rather than for RW nomination/tagset cleanup?

[aphrodite_mine]

Definitely a job for the big bosses. Unfortunately, we can't change where uncategorized fandoms land on our end.

[muccamukk]

The Mummy Series (2) ↑
Evy Carnahan
Evy Carnahan O'Connell

Are the same person, I think. One's her maiden name, and one's her married name. Unless I have some drastic misunderstanding of the character from not having seen the fourth film.

I don't see duplications to other fandoms on your list of okay topics, but in case they are:

In this year's round of Marvel Fandom Wackamole, all of the New Mutants (Comics) characters, and all of the Guardians of the Galaxy (Film) characters have duplicated into Marvel 616.

All of the Doctor Who (1963) characters have duplicated into Doctor Who (Big Finish), but they are all in both, so I'm not sure where they originated.

(If not, never mind)

[aphrodite_mine]

You are definitely right. Nominator, any preference which version lives and which one vanishes into the night?

[muccamukk]

Another fandom creep: Lwaxana Troi is under TNG and DS9, and I'm pretty sure she was only nominated under TNG, but she was in both shows.

[aphrodite_mine]

Oh Lordy. I think that was an omission by way of STRONG WISHES that it wouldn't be necessary.

Nominator, if you see this, would you please identify which characters were meant for only the Big Finish audio?

I should be able to fix-ish the Marvel fun.

[aphrodite_mine]

Evy = fixed
New Mutants = fixed
Guardians = fixed
DW = should be fixed

[gehayi]

For Discworld - Terry Pratchett, there's a listing for Amber (Discworld). Her full name is Amber Petty in the books, and that's how she's listed in the Discworld wiki as well:

http://wiki.lspace.org/mediawiki/Amber_Petty

[aphrodite_mine]

Fixed, thank you.

[paranoidangel]

In The Librarians (Movies) these two characters are the same person:

Charlene (The Librarian (Movies))
Charlene (The Librarian)

I nominated the first one, the second one crept over from The Librarians (TV 2014).

[aphrodite_mine]

Should be fixed.

Mod

[aphrodite_mine]

Thanks for your notes so far! I'm unable to actually make changes until at least tomorrow, but keep noting! I'll comment back here when I make updates.

Re: Mod

[aphrodite_mine]

And everything down to here should be resolved! Please let me know if issues remain.

[anaraine]

Whoops! I didn't realize there was a canonical tag for the Junk Lady when I made my noms.

In Labyrinth (1986) the nom for "The Junk Lady" could be changed to "Junk Lady (Labyrinth)" link.

[aphrodite_mine]

Fixed!

[rosedamask]

The dangers of nominating from audiobook: for Shirley - Charlotte Bronte (Books and Literature), Rose York should be Rose Yorke. :)

[aphrodite_mine]

Fixed!

[evewithanapple]

"Turner Series- Courtney Milan" and "Perfect Creature" are both under "Uncategorized Fandoms." The Turner series is a series of books, and Perfect Creature is a movie. Also, Zuleika from "The Steel Seraglio" seems to have gotten attached to a character of the same name from Joseph King of Dreams- they actually don't have anything to do with each other.

[aphrodite_mine]

Uncategorized fandoms we can't do anything about, but I'll fix Zuleika!

[sirvalkyrie]

Under Power Rangers Dino Charge "Shelby (Dino Charge)" should be "Shelby Watkins."

http://powerrangers.wikia.com/wiki/Shelby_Watkins

[aphrodite_mine]

Thank you! Should be fixed.

[skaianet]

Hi! Princess Bubblegum and Marceline from Adventure Time are throwing up an error that says they were nominated for It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia (although they're not listed in there).

[aphrodite_mine]

Try refreshing? They were rejected for being over on tag counts (on FFN).

[illyriasacolyte]

What's with the Darla (AtS) tag? She's nominated under both Buffy and Angel, and has appeared in both shows, but has the Angel tag even under her Buffy nom. Is this something on A03's end? Does it matter?

[aphrodite_mine]

I'll fix her :)

[gehayi]

In "To Kill a Mockingbird - Harper Lee," a character is listed as Mayella Ewel. That should be Mayella Ewell.

[rebcake]

I'll second the question about Darla being listed in both Buffy and Angel. Seems like once would be enough (in Angel).

Also, I nominated the "potential slayers" in Buffy and it was rejected, though it is an existing tag. I know there aren't enough fics about all of them put together, so I'm curious about the reasoning. Is it because it's cheating to nom them all in a lump — and thereby getting a whole bunch of rare women in one fell swoop — or something else? It just seemed silly to nominate just one or two of them, since they don't get much love. But any of these would be great:

Vi, Rona, Annabelle, Chloe, Amanda, Chao Ahn, Molly, Caridad, Eve, Shannon, etc.

[aphrodite_mine]

It was rejected on the basis of being a tag that represents more than one character.

If you would like to choose a potential to replace the rejected tag, that would be fine.

[gehayi]

There's a listing for Lady Ariel (Romeo x Juliet). The character's full name seems to be Ariel de Farnese.

[aphrodite_mine]

Fixed!

[teaotter]

There is a character in Defiance (tv) that doesn't belong there:

Ava Berlin Renner

... I think she's Jeremy Renner's daughter, and is therefore an RPF character? She's definitely not on Defiance.

(There is a Defiance character whose name is similar - Jessica "Berlin" Rainier. She's been nominated and approved.)

[aphrodite_mine]

...That I think takes the prize for the weirdest glitch this year. *hands award to tiny Renner and deletes her from tag set*

[moontyger]

Under Toaru Kagaku no Railgun | A Certain Scientific Railgun, Misaka Mikoto and Shirai Kuroko are listed both with disambigs and without. Honestly, I find this puzzling, since it wouldn't let me nominate them without the disambiguations (because they were also nominated under A Certain Magical Index), but I guess it let someone else do it?

[(Anonymous)]

Not Mod: they were probably initially nominated under Index, then after you submitted them with disambigs under Railgun, wormed into Index thanks to the "child tags tend to float into every fandom they're associated with by wranglers, even if the tag set mod tried to associate them to only one fandom for that tag set" bug.

More category creep

[muccamukk]

Andromache (Homer) has jumped from "HOMER - Works" into "The Aeneid - Virgil"

Gilmith is in both The Lord of the Rings and the Silmarillion. I THINK she was nominated under LotR.

Cleante al-Faisal, Mara (Star Trek) & T'Shael have jumped from Star Trek - Various Authors to Star Trek TOS.

Re: More category creep

[aphrodite_mine]

Thank you! I definitely managed to catch a lot going in, but not everything. I'm going to leave Gilmith but fix the others.

[lilacsigil]

Ming-Hua and P'Li are listed under Avatar: The Last Airbender and Avatar: The Legend of Korra. They should only be under Avatar: The Legend of Korra.

[aphrodite_mine]

Fixed :)

[(Anonymous)]

Under Agents of SHIELD, Agent 33 and Kara Lynn Palamas are the same character. Thus far, she has been referred to as Agent 33 on the show, but according to the Marvel comics the series is based on, her real name is Kara Lynn Palamas.

[aphrodite_mine]

I just deleted Kara Lynn since that isn't the canon name (yet) for the series.

[(Anonymous)]

For some reason Caitlin Snow is not showing up under The Flash in the tag set, despite the fact that she's showing up as approved under my nominations.

[aphrodite_mine]

Hmm. I manually added her to The Flash, so you should be good!